Ranking NHL Playoff Wild-Card Teams by Tier

The NHL’s playoff seeding system, designed to reward elite teams with easier first-round matchups, often backfires, as seen with unexpected losses by top teams to lower-seeded wild-card teams, making the playoffs unpredictable and challenging for division winners.

The NHL’s playoff seeding throws in a few wild-card teams. It’s meant to give top teams an easy start. But, oh, how that plan can backfire. Just look at the Tampa Bay Lightning in 2019 or the Boston Bruins last year. Both top seeds, both upset early.

Yes, securing a division crown offers perks like home ice. But it’s no guarantee of an easy opponent. With just a week left in the season, the battle for those wild-card spots is intense.

**Do not pass GO, do not collect $200.** That’s the reality for division winners facing wild-card teams. The gap between divisions can lead to surprises. Take the 2023-24 Tampa Bay Lightning, for instance. They’re not the powerhouse of previous years, but they’re nobody’s idea of a pushover.

Since acquiring Anthony Duclair, Tampa’s been on fire. Their offense and defense rank in the top six. And special teams? Top three. It’s not just Kucherov leading the charge; Stamkos has been red-hot too. Despite some defensive question marks, goalie Andrei Vasilevskiy is finding his form. Not exactly the reward for a 105+ point season.

Tampa’s wild-card status points to flaws in the NHL playoff format. Meanwhile, the Vegas Golden Knights, despite being eighth in the West, are no easy out. Their recent Stanley Cup victory and seasoned players make them formidable. Injuries have slowed them, but their core group and high-profile trades keep them competitive.

**Trap teams.** The Nashville Predators and Pittsburgh Penguins are lurking. Nashville’s underdog story is compelling. They’ve been on a tear since a humiliating loss sparked their season. Their mix of veterans and emerging talent has them poised for an upset.

Pittsburgh’s journey has been rocky, battling through a tough division and inconsistent play. But with their talent, they’ve turned a corner since the trade deadline. Crosby and company are peaking at the right time.

**Frisky.** The Los Angeles Kings and New York Islanders won’t go quietly. L.A.’s defense is a nightmare for opponents, even if their offense isn’t flashy. New York’s gritty playstyle and emerging stars keep them in the hunt, despite aging veterans and defensive woes.

**Who let these guys in?** The Detroit Red Wings defy expectations. Their early success and resilience have them in playoff contention. Yet, their defensive shortcomings are hard to ignore. As for the Washington Capitals and Philadelphia Flyers, they’re hanging on, driven by different motivations. Washington chases history with Ovechkin, while Philadelphia embraces a rebuild.

In the Stanley Cup Playoffs, no team can be overlooked. Every match-up has the potential to surprise, proving once again why hockey’s postseason is one of the most unpredictable and exciting in sports.

Alex Thompson
Alex Thompson
Alex Thompson is a Senior Writer for HockeyMonitor. With a background in Sports Media, Alex joined the team in 2022. He focuses on providing the latest hockey news, game scores, and fresh NHL trade rumors.

Related NHL News